Should ‘American Idol’ keep four judges next season?
-
- May
- 5
Personally, here at Remote Access, we can’t get enough of Kara DioGuardi, the newest judge on “American Idol.”
Maybe we love her because she’s a local gal: She grew up in New Rochelle.
Maybe it’s because she’s offered up more water-cooler-worthy bloopers than Paula this season. (Anyone else up for “Studio 57?”)
Anyway, we hope she sticks around for Season 9, but not everyone feels the same way.
And those Kara-haters will be upset to hear this tidbit that just hit TVGuide.com:
According to Simon Cowell, all four judges will probably be returning.
(Simon has also hinted that he might leave when his contract expires after next season; Paula’s is up this year.)
If true, is the four-judge format a good thing?
Should Kara stay – and Paula go?
Or would you be happy to see Kara say “artistry “one last time – and then walk away for good?
(Photo courtesy of FOX)

















